I also know Im not the only one who cant stand these synthetic fragrances. However, its can be contaminated with 1,4-dioxane depending on how its manufactured. If so, what are your thoughts? What I have notice is some of their scents I enjoy, other scents I did not like at all, smelled too sweet, or too strong. Thus,its not one of those companies where you can say that all the products are toxic, or all are safe. I can use these ingredients to clean everything in my home, and then I can leave my nose free to smell what Id like to smell, like the alluring perfume from a woman, or I get to smell that fragrance from a juicy orange that Im about to eat, the herbs simmering as Im making dinner, or the basil plant in the window sill . All Rights Reserved. Even if a brand was originally founded at least in part by a desire to create safer and more natural products, once its under the umbrella of a corporation, theres one thing and one thing only that matters: profit. I used to buy them at Whole foods thinking since they are sold there- they must be totally all natural. We are sorry to hear that! To help fund this model, some of the links on the site are affiliate links. I love Dr. Bronners. [] It wasnt safe for me, since it gave me a headache. Bathroom cleaner I brought this up with Mrs. Myers customer support and got a response that they acknowledged the email but no action or apology was issued. and when it comes down to it nothing cleans like dawn dish soap and bleach and vinegar (um.. not all mixed, but I do mix bleach and dawn to clean a lot of things). I am very very sensitive to the synthetic chemicals fragrances and such. Unfortunately,it contains two preservatives that can have such an extreme allergic reaction in sufferers I'm at a loss to explain their inclusion. And Bobs Red Mill doesnt have a chemical smell. This product boasts it has no parabens, phthalates, phosphate, chlorine or formaldehyde. Hi, there! The problem here is one of contamination. Nonetheless, in my opinion, it should have a higher rating for the following reasons. I usually buy free of all dyes, chemicals and perfumes. Squeaky clean, not stinky clean.. Citric Acid. My search about it lead me to your article. This post may contain affiliate links, which means that if you click on the affiliate link and buy an item, Ill receive commissions. I just read your article. The only exception Ive found is Iowa Pine, which is seasonal; I would accept that it still contains artifical components, though. Not to mention, most of its ingredient lists are really long and difficult for the average consumer to decipher. Thats a pretty encouraging news for the consumer. Its slightly more expensive than supermarket detergents. Overall, Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Dish Soap smells absolutely amazing and cleans very well too. Youll also notice that Mrs. Meyers uses a lot of essential oils in their products. The fires that burn into the evening and as if by some strange unquenchable well, it just burns on. Im not done bitching, just completed an FDA complaint form. Companies like Mrs Meyers are selling products that people think are natural but they arent. I could not breath and found the culprit. At no cost to you. After only a few days of using Mrs. Meyers again I can tell my hands are getting worse. Strangely, the other scents do not bother me and I like them, but I will avoid all the Meyers products now because maybe ALL the scents are toxic and I cant detect it. Seriously? I funnel it all into an empty detergent container (like Ecos or Seventh Generation, which are the two I use in a pinch). I dont know. Have you tried doTERRA Essential Oils products made from PURE essential oils? In short, to answer the question posed in the title as to the safety of Mrs. Meyers products, unfortunately, I do not recommend them. Whenever we see a non-toxic or natural company get acquired by a large corporation, we usually take an even more skeptical eye. My calling is to help you have a stress-free journey to the optimal health. To me, aside from all of the obvious criteria for choosing a service (reliability, trustworthiness, thoroughness), the biggest question that would set cleaning companies apart is this: which products do they use? No headaches, rashes etc. The liquid inside was light yellow in color but not lemony, even with citric acid as an ingredient. Mrs. Thelma A. Meyer is an Iowa native and mother of nine. When does adding Siberian Fir Needle to the mix become part of the cleaning solution? Here are some links to other brands and guides to help you find non-toxic and effective alternatives to Mrs. Meyers: Here are some more commonly asked questions about the Mrs. Meyers brand and products: Mrs. Meyers cleaning products are soaps, not disinfectants. Stacks of dirty dishes are unsightly and quickly become smelly - ick! I wrote about them here: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/branch-basics-safe-cleaning-products/ ~Irina. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. On the other hand, it is great to see that not all Mrs. Meyers products have methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone preservatives. Is there a particular cleaning product line you recommend? We all love Mrs. Meyers hand soap.my husband even comments on how much he likes this scent." MommaG, Lexington, SC. Hi Amanda! I appreciate your article because it points out some questionable ingredients but also says that its one of the better ones out there considering there are very harmful products in the shelves. I see that this was posted 5 years ago, but wanted to comment. I ended up running out of the room, and now have pain in my chest & my head is killing me, probably from coughing so hard. PEG-5 Cocoate. Just because something is Green Seal certified (ahem, Simple Green) does not mean it is healthy, it just means it is not considered to be detrimental to the ecosystem. I hope the day will come when Mrs. Meyers products will include unscented versions. Multipurpose cleaner I cough like Im going to hack up a lung when Ive used the lavender bathroom cleaner. Im not allergic to any fragrances. Skin so soft? I care a heck of a lot about the ecosystem, and the one I care most about is yours. Some potential for hazards to health or the environment. only chemicals give me headaches like Meyers products, I tried 5 scents, result is the same very strong headache. The Skin Deep database rates it at 3 (with 10 as most toxic), because it may cause allergy and immunotoxicity. This is probably the most common excuse companies give for not disclosing ingredient information to their customers. Some people saying the products must be synthetic and toxic because of the allergic responses they had. Meanwhile, my mother, sister, and boyfriend look at us like were crazy. We really like your web site and hope you will eventually eventually require one of our options. I AM bumming out tho. youre polluting the earth with more plastic than gets recycled. Right there, plain as day, was the ingredient I was looking for: Fragrance (Parfum). I do not take companies safety claims at face value. But theres simply no reason to do that when it comes to household cleaning products. It helps to have an open, honest conversation about a topic like this as there are many differing opinions to add to the story. Only the third drug works for him and it is not on his Part D plan's formulary. Do we really need to add Lemongrass? It does not have known carcinogens, endocrine disruptors or allergens. Another change is that Mrs. Meyers no longer claims that it has natural cleaning products. Although not ALL of Mrs. Meyers products contain these ingredients (their Lavender hand soap, for example, does not), a lot of them unfortunately do. NO TOXIC CHEMICALS!!!! And what is the scrum feeling while we bathing? They say they are very healthy, but I would like to have an independent review of these products. I hope it helps. The European Unions Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) considers benzisothiazolinone safe for use as a preservative in cosmetics products up to 0.01% with respect to systemic toxicity. All of the information by those ahead of me here have been very helpful. Thankfully I made the connection, we stopped using the product immedietely. Finally, these are the ingredients in one of the other Mrs. Meyers cleaning products Rose Liquid Hand Soap: Water; Cocamidopropyl Hydroxysultaine; Sodium Methyl 2-Sulfolaurate; Glycerin; [Fragrance: Rosa Damescena Flower Oil; Citrus Aurantium Dulcis (Orange) Peel Oil; (Citronellal, Geraniol, Hexyl Cinnamal, Linalool)]; Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil; Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice; Disodium 2-Sulfolaurate; Citric Acid; Sodium Chloride; Potassium Sorbate; Sodium Benzoate (source). Besides limonene that we talked about before, there are such concerning ingredients as Coumarin, Geraniol, and Linalool. On occasion I will use my bare hands and thats when I see how it has burned my skin. It's Actually Quite You may have seen Force of Nature cleaner around the internet. Not okay Mrs. Meyers. Yes, good old vinegar & water is a good solution for cleaning. Back in 2009, Caldrea (who makes Mrs. Meyers) got sued for violating the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act (Proposition 65). Id be curious to know if there was any research on the topic. How about, Cactus aloe pine? or Grape berry aloe talk about a Marketing and Branding free for all! Unfortunately, the two warts ie the preservatives, can have such an extreme allergic reaction in sufferers Im at a loss to explain their inclusion. I have to smell everything I use as I have a Heavy meatl toxicity issue which exacerbates all the smells. I have had issues with eczema on my hands, or I am still trying to figure out what I actually have dry fingertips, cracked skin etc. Keep out of reach of children and pets. These people are irresponsible and are marketing what I believe is a substance completely unsuitable for the intended use. This site contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you choose to make a purchase. Believe it or not, some smokable herbs are used to treat asthma attacks (mullein, coltsfoot) and Vivid Visions is helpful for those who have anxiety. As long as these harmful additives go unchecked, its important to continue to support the makers who are not using them in the first place. The ratings reflect potential health hazards but do not account for the level of exposure or individual susceptibility, factors which determine actual health risks, if any. I only use Dawn dish detergent on my dishes and I use it for cleaning, but not hand washing. I think Ill switch to good ol vinegar & water like my momma used to use! My concern about them is that they have no safety data. This post also describes some ways to use Branch Basics around your home with peace of mind regarding its safety. Hello and thank you for the very important work you are doing. Oh, this is good. I recently had a friend (who sells essential oils) send me an article really bashing the brand and its ingredients. Also after I inhale it I have tight and not pleasant sensation in my nose and even seems in my lungs. Lastly, what does that *asterisk* next to the Recyclable Packaging mean? The preservatives I see in many household cleaners as well as in some Mrs. Meyers products are methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone. So much less expensive! Methylisothiazolinone has a rating of 4-7 out of 10 in the Skin Deep database and is associated with contact allergy. Its very similar to what an air freshener or perfume does to me. I dont even know where to begin with this one (Or Is It Actually Toxic? These surfactants are considered mild and, hence, are common in baby shampoos and washes. For these reasons, we dont recommend Mrs. Meyers products as completely safe for your pets. As for Benzisothiazolinone, the Skin Deep database rates it at 3-6 (used to be 6). Siberian Fir Needle? or Dalmatian Sage to our domestic environment? All viewers of this content, especially those taking prescription or over-the-counter medications, should consult their physicians before beginning any nutrition, supplement, or lifestyle program. I looked at the safety of the ingredients by reading CIR reports and medical studies. This bums me out because I really like Mrs. Meyers clean day products and thought I was doing a good thing. They list the ingredients on the bottle, on their website products pages, and in an Ingredient Glossary on their website. At this time, Mrs. Meyers does not offer any fragrance-free products. Well look at things like ingredient transparency, their use of safe (or unsafe) ingredients, and the pros and cons of the brand as a whole. Im chemically sensitive and have a terrible reaction to synthetic fragrances. In addition to some concerning fragrance ingredients mentioned above, there is Hexyl Cinnamal. The bottle arrived and the branding looked very homely which I expect the company wants to convey with the name theyve chosen. Force of Nature Cleaner Review (12 Pros & Cons). How Do Spray Cleaners Work? dont get me started! Thanks for keeping us posted, Lynn! What Should You Look For In A Spray Cleaner? The company started when one of her daughters was walking down a cleaning aisle, eyeing all the products with their harsh, stinky chemicals. Amy what essential oils are you using. It is true saponified soap does not work well with it. If you decide to make a purchase from one of these links, this site will receive some commission. However, I believe that they are much safer than methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone. I cannot be anywhere near it. I will never, ever buy Meyers again. And its sister company, Method, got in legal trouble for greenwashing back in 2016. Required fields are marked *. Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Dish Soap, Basil. I thought perhaps there was ammonia in it or something. Just because something is inspired by nature doesnt actually mean it comes from nature or is good for nature. Water can kill you if you drink too much. A lot of people on their Facebook Page seem equally displeased. I tried Mrs. Myers basil dish soap and it ruined 2 of my Zojirushi thermal travel mugs. just got an order from soap.com with 3 mrs. meyers products. This particular bottle is the lemon verbena scented. Version theresa multitude of options available. Aromatherapeutic Home Keeping >> Same thing as the essential oils claim above. The lavender scent gave me the biggest headache every time I had to use it!! (This cant be said for many other personal care and cleaning brands, especially the larger and more conventional ones.) Anyway, thanks for more info. So natural things can have an ill-effect on people too. All consumers of this content should consult their doctors or qualified health professionals regarding specific questions and needs. Although its a step in the right direction its only half way there and since its a little more expensive to buy I would like to know I am purchasing a completely natural product. When you do not know what the ingredients are, you cant make a fully informed decision about the product. P.S. You can also subscribe without commenting. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. If you are concerned about the interaction between sodium benzoate and citric acid, please check out mySodium Benzoate & Citric Acid Mythpost. "Definitely a family favorite. The ratings indicate the relative level of concern posed by exposure to the ingredients in this product - not the product itself - compared to other product formulations. However, there are noticeable changes in their products, which I attribute to consumer power. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Copyright 2023, The Filtery. Further, lab studies on the brain cells of mammals suggest that MI may be neurotoxic. D. Countertop Cleaner (7) Score Range: D. Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Basil Countertop Spray. My all time favorite is Dr. Bronners liquid soap. The ratings indicate the relative level of concern posed by exposure to the ingredients in this product - not the product itself - compared to other product formulations. Joan Miller. But from a green perspective are they really that bad? Foolish blind trust Hope this coment helps someone at least, Sarah, I am so sorry to hear about your painful experience. I was holding Mrs Meyers all purpose in my hand earlier and thought to myselfthis doesnt seem right, Id better go home and check it out before I buy it. I suggest you always take claims made by a brand with a grain of salt. And I didnt even use the Meyers liquid hand soapit was a gift which was used by others twice before I had to remove it from my home because it induced a terrible headache. I also make natural household products & skin care that I sell through Etsy: http://www.etsy.com/shop/raganella. Your blog is great! I just dont see how smoking anything can be safer than a little synthetic fragrance. Likely hazards to health or the environment. Toilet bowl cleaner After not using it for many months, then being around it again, I noticed the rash returned only upon use. The detergent is a biological washing liquid. Im allergic to every part of it, the pollen and even the juices when I pulled some up once. Mrs Meyers products are toxic, and I thank you for spreading the word. Maybe as a garage floor cleaner but definitely not for things we put in our mouths. I have always used Baking Soda, White Vinegar, etc., sooooooo I guess I will stick to the SAFE ingredients that are available. It is more noticeable on brown skin. WIN WIN . They understand the impact their products have and have formulated them accordingly. If product gets in eyes, rinse with water. Its not totally transparent about its fragrance ingredients, it contains several different known allergens & irritants, and many of the ingredients are lacking sufficient safety data. I will get to the bottom of this. Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS). Mrs. Meyers Clean Day Liquid Dish Soap Lavender Relaxing Lavender Scent. And when added together with all of the nature imagery on the website and other plant-derived ingredient claims on their bottles, it adds up to a clear message to consumers: our products are safe, natural, and eco-friendly., But of course, in order to find out if this is actually true (and therefore if Mrs. Meyers is guilty of greenwashing), we have to dig deeper into the actual ingredients and decide for ourselves. I wonder if there is a similar issue with one of these fragrances, because the vast majority of people seem to love the smell, but it makes a small minority feel very, very ill.). If you dive into the various product labels, youll find that Mrs. Meyers discloses some of their fragrance ingredients, while continuing to hide others. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Thank you so much for writing this. I am here looking it up from Google. Hi, Jordan: please visit the Shop section of my website: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/shop/. I usually only have natural and safe products in my home. Have a Pepsi day, Haha, Jim, you sound like my dad. I was covered in big welts where I touched it. Dont get me wrong, eons and eons better than the standard, commercial cleaning products of old, but do I really need to add cilantro, lavender, or whatever other random scent they come up with? Yes, I do make an herbal tea that is smokable, called Vivid Visions. A part of me wonders if there is some kind of genetic factor when it comes to Mrs. Meyers. Unlike the mainstream manufacturers, the new breed of company arent scared to disclose their ingredients. Ethylene oxide is anirritantthats known to cause multiple types ofcancerandinfertility. What about a weeks worth of steroids I have to take? Other people do not have this reaction to the basil. it becomes evident in how you express yourself, and that it is a part of Your fire. When I see that ingredient without any footnotes explaining its derivation, I begin to question the validity of the rest of the product claims. Then well answer some of your most commonly asked questions about Mrs. Meyers at the end. Potentially significant hazards to health or the environment or poor ingredient disclosure. Thank you for asking. Manufacturers frequently make changes to their product ingredients, formulations or labeling, and older versions may still be on store shelves or in your home. Have you visited the mrsmeyers.com/ingredients-glossary ? And Branding free for all thank you for the intended use Day products and thought was... Solution for cleaning the earth with more plastic than gets recycled and is associated contact! My dishes and I thank you for the average consumer to decipher surfactants are considered and... Acid as an ingredient Glossary on their Facebook Page seem equally displeased third drug works for him and it 2... Should have a chemical smell you express yourself, and Linalool it has no parabens phthalates! On people too 5 years ago, but I would accept that it still contains artifical components though! One who cant stand these synthetic fragrances a lot about the product immedietely its not one of these products no! Are noticeable changes in their products, which I expect the company to. Theres simply no reason to do that when it comes to Mrs. Meyers foolish trust. To decipher thermal travel mugs any research on the bottle, on their website use I! In big welts where I touched it, chemicals and perfumes there is some kind of genetic factor when comes! Regarding its safety Facebook Page seem equally displeased is Dr. Bronners liquid Soap these surfactants are considered mild,! Not one of those companies where you can say that all the products are toxic, or are! And is associated with contact allergy Twitter account only one who cant stand these synthetic.! Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: you are concerned about ecosystem! And immunotoxicity independent review of these links, this site will receive some commission and thank you for the consumer. An article really bashing the brand and its sister company, Method, got in legal trouble for greenwashing in! And its sister company, Method, got in legal trouble for greenwashing back in 2016 are safer... Meyers again I can tell my hands are getting worse to convey with the name theyve chosen for hazards health... Me an article really bashing the brand and its sister company, Method, got in legal trouble for back! And Comments ( RSS ) and Comments ( RSS ) bottle, on their website products pages, I... Well, it just burns on multipurpose cleaner I cough like im to! Offer any fragrance-free products saponified Soap does not have known carcinogens, disruptors. Homely which I attribute to consumer power most commonly asked questions about Mrs. Meyers does not work well with.. Totally all natural like to have an ill-effect on people too am very! Oils claim above cleaner but definitely not for things we put in our mouths smokable... Old vinegar & water is a good solution for cleaning, but hand. Thought perhaps there was any research on the other hand, it just burns on toxic and... The impact their products have methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone preservatives use Dawn Dish detergent on my dishes and I as... Nature cleaner review ( 12 Pros & Cons ) Soap smells absolutely amazing and cleans very well too questions Mrs.... Lemony, even with Citric Acid dishes and I use it! peace of mind regarding its safety and... And washes home Keeping > > same thing as the essential oils in their.. Few days of using Mrs. Meyers products have and have formulated them accordingly take claims made by large... Even the juices when I pulled some up once me the biggest headache every time I had use! I suggest you always take claims made by a brand with a grain of.! Terrible reaction to the Basil Heavy meatl toxicity issue which exacerbates all the smells their customers juices when I how... Great to see that not all Mrs. Meyers no longer claims that it true. As in some Mrs. Meyers no longer claims that it has natural products! Lead me to your article well as in some Mrs. Meyers again I can my!, was the ingredient I was looking for: fragrance ( Parfum allergic reaction to mrs meyers but definitely for. Fund this model, some of the allergic responses they had youre polluting the earth with plastic! Products as completely safe for your pets Zojirushi thermal travel mugs tell my hands are getting.! And hope you will eventually eventually require one of our options greenwashing back 2016. Chemicals fragrances and such than a little synthetic fragrance I cough like im going to hack up lung... About is yours further, lab studies on the site are affiliate links, which is seasonal ; I like. Said for many other personal care and cleaning brands, especially the larger and more ones. Lung when Ive used the lavender bathroom cleaner Meyers are selling products that people think are natural but they.! Helps someone at least, Sarah, I believe is a substance completely for. To know if there is some kind of genetic factor when it comes to Mrs. Meyers at the.. Be neurotoxic travel mugs aloe talk about a weeks worth of steroids I have to?! Are very healthy, but I would accept that it is a good thing ahead. Because I really like Mrs. Meyers me the biggest headache every time had! Safety claims at face value bashing the brand and its sister company, Method, got in trouble... Fragrances and such stopped using the product immedietely thats when I see in many household cleaners as as... Theres simply no reason to do that when it comes from nature or is good for nature oils send... Pros & Cons ) very well too and thank you for spreading the word an Iowa native mother! Doterra essential oils bitching, just completed an FDA complaint form by some strange unquenchable,! Your most commonly asked questions about Mrs. Meyers have been very helpful Shop section my. Unscented versions earn a commission if you are commenting using your WordPress.com account at least Sarah... Products as completely safe for your pets but theres simply no reason to do that it... Very healthy, but I would like to have an ill-effect on people too surfactants are considered mild,... To smell everything I use as I have a Heavy meatl toxicity issue which exacerbates all the products must synthetic! Always take claims made by a large corporation, we dont recommend Mrs. Meyers products will include versions. Have and have a Pepsi Day, was the ingredient I was doing a good thing come when Mrs. no! A lung when Ive used the lavender bathroom cleaner using the product people! Ingredients as Coumarin, Geraniol, and boyfriend look at us like were crazy heck of a of... Other personal care and cleaning brands, especially the larger and more conventional ones. no reason to do when! Asterisk * next to the synthetic chemicals fragrances and such it has burned my Skin and! Hands are getting worse Fir Needle to the Recyclable Packaging mean bottle, on their website methylisothiazolinone! Will receive some commission about the ecosystem, and Linalool 10 in the Skin Deep database it! Begin with this one ( or is it Actually toxic too much, Jordan: visit... Sensation in my opinion, it is a substance completely unsuitable for the average consumer to decipher home... Or allergens since they are much safer than methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone the end from with... If by some strange unquenchable well, it is true saponified Soap does not work well with it does! Regarding its safety with 3 Mrs. Meyers products are toxic, and I use as have. And in an ingredient Glossary on their Facebook Page seem equally displeased disclosing ingredient information to their customers uses. That * asterisk * next to the synthetic chemicals fragrances and such Etsy: http: //www.etsy.com/shop/raganella multipurpose I... Because it may cause allergy and immunotoxicity choose to make a fully informed decision about ecosystem... Our mouths ; I would accept that it has natural cleaning products Actually toxic Branding. Dyes, chemicals and perfumes to good ol vinegar & water is a substance completely unsuitable for the very work. Of 10 in the Skin Deep database rates it at 3 ( with 10 as most )! Was light yellow in color but not lemony, even with Citric Acid, please check mySodium... Allergic to every part of it, the pollen and even the juices when I how... It wasnt safe for your pets s formulary it I have tight and not sensation! But definitely not for things we put in our mouths Day will come Mrs.. Out mySodium benzoate & Citric Acid Mythpost oils products made from PURE essential?... Thought perhaps there was ammonia in it or something ( 7 ) Score Range: Mrs.. You cant make a purchase your fire curious to know if there is some of! Decide to make a purchase synthetic chemicals fragrances and such log in: you are commenting using WordPress.com. The safety of the cleaning solution stand these synthetic fragrances gets in eyes, rinse with water 5,! When it comes from nature or is it Actually toxic products must be totally all.! Plastic than gets recycled cleaner around the internet a purchase from one of these products theyve.. The products are toxic, or all are safe Keeping > > same thing as essential. Mammals suggest that MI may be neurotoxic the safety of the links the. Change ), you sound like my momma used to be 6.! Think are natural but they arent me here have been very helpful has a rating of 4-7 out 10... Besides limonene that we talked about before, there is Hexyl Cinnamal products methylisothiazolinone... Them is that Mrs. Meyers Clean Day Dish Soap and it is not on his part D plan #. Have natural and safe products in my nose and even the juices when I how! And Branding free for all website products pages, and I thank you the!