9 Moreover, one may claim that because nothing can limit God, he/she is continually active, or has the power to affirm existence eternally. WebEINSTEIN BELIEVES IN "SPINOZA'S GOD"; Scientist Defines His Faith in Reply, to Cablegram From Rabbi Here. In 1656, Spinoza was excommunicated. Im locked in. One reason why he believes this to be so is that the natural order displays its coherency to people, due to their existing only one substance God, or Nature, and thus whatever ultimately flows from him/her as an immaterial substance has a matching effect on him/her as a corporeal one. Baruch De Spinoza was a Dutch philosopher considered one of the three great rationalist in the century of philosophy, along with French Descartes. ), Responsibility begins with the willingness to take the stand that one is cause in the matter of ones life. Spinoza also states that it is only of the nature of God, or the one substance, to be infinite and eternal. Stop asking for forgiveness, theres nothing to forgive. From this, it follows that there can only be one substance in nature, God since the incompatibleness of two or more substances would not only stop them from interacting, but also bar them from causing one another to come to be. That is, God ultimately sets the conditions for the existence of modes, and thus, it is the case that they are not limitless, but rather compelled by the will of another. Due to God being infinite, it follows that nothing has the power to compel or cause him/her to act in any way that defies the course of his/her nature. 91, From this it follows that affects can either assists people or deter them from their desires to live, or aid or restrain their innate abilities to be. - The Divine Mother. 61 In other words, peoples bodies are made up of smaller bodies that are either at rest or in motion just like their bodies. God as Perfect and Not the Cause of Sadness. 45 That is, though thinking things express God in specific and determinate ways, they nevertheless express his/her essence, since as modes it is of their nature to do so, and thus, God must possess thought, since, without it, modes would be unable to express that attribute. Man can, indeed, act contrarily to the decrees of God, as far as they have been written like laws in the minds of ourselves or the prophets, but against that eternal decree of God, which is written in universal nature, and has regard to the course of nature as a whole, he can do nothing. Remarkable Last Words (or Near-Last Words). Spinoza calls the state of mind associated with sadness, melancholy, and its matching physical effect, pain. The said Espinoza should be excommunicated and expelled from the people of Israel. 43 Hence, since God, in the end, determines the conditions of all thinking things, it follows that he/she necessarily possesses the attribute of thought, because without it those thinking things would cease to be conceivable. In other words, because the mind and body concur, it follows that what negatively affects the minds awareness of itself, must also affect the bodys ability to act. Consequently, since God does not cause inadequate ideas, and because sadness derives from those types of ideas, it is the case that people who believe that he/she is against them or has caused them sorrows are in error. That is, if God were not equivalent to Nature, there would necessarily be two Gods, one to facilitate the laws of thought, and the other the laws of extension, which cannot be, since the natural order presents itself as a unified whole.49, Furthermore, God is necessarily a corporeal substance since if he/she were not, there would be nowhere for his/her modes to extend. 46 In other words, because all thinking things ultimately derive from God, it follows that he/she bears some relation to them, and since they express thought by thinking, it follows that God must possess that attribute since if he did not, then they would be unable to convey it. 94. 64 Consequently, because God, as an infinitely extended being, does not match any other body in him/her, it follows that he/she cannot alter when they undergo change. The best introduction to the subject in recent memory. Live as if there is not. He endorses a strong form of necessitarianism in which everything is categorically necessary opposed to the weaker form of conditional necessity embraced by most compatibilists, and he contends that there is no room in such a world for divine or creaturely free will. Thus, Spinoza is a free will skeptic. . Stop blaming me for your miserable life; I never told you there was anything wrong with you or that you were a sinner, or that your sexuality was a bad thing. Cold deterministic rationalism? Early in The Ethics Spinoza argues that there is only one substance, which is absolutely infinite, self-caused, and eternal. 18 That is, nothing is as active as God is, because the activity of all existence cannot eternally continue if it relies on anything that can be inactive. As men's habits of mind differ, so that some more readily embrace one form of faith, some another, for what moves one to pray may move another to scoff, I conclude that everyone should be free to choose for himself the foundations of his creed, and that faith should be judged only by its fruits; each would then obey God freely with his whole heart, while nothing would be publicly honored save justice and charity. Nothing happens by chance. Furthermore, Spinoza continues to claim that like all other shapes, bodies retain the effects of what causes them to move or come to rest, and reflect those effects too. All beings are birthed directly from the Heart of One. Spinoza makes a similar reference when he states that God as an idea is like the idea of a circle that matches the reality of a circle universally. Responsibility is not burden, fault, praise, blame, credit, shame or guilt. Spinoza was born in Amsterdam in the 17th century of a businessman father who was successful but not wealthy. 60 By this, Spinoza means that God, as an extended substance, causes the conditions, or the laws of his/her attribute of extension which ultimately enables peoples bodies to come to be. Stop reading alleged sacred scriptures that have nothing to do with me. One reason why Spinoza believes this is that a person, who is under the influence of inadequate ideas, do not have a clear understanding of how to strive to continue to live, which, in turn, clouds ones view of reality. Philosophers that are significant to him and his studies are Parmenides, Plato, Plotinus, Descartes, Spinoza, Kant, and Hegel. 86 At the same time, affects are still ideational, and thus they are compatible with the intelligibleness of peoples minds. One reason why Spinoza makes this claim is that joy acts upon people in ways that only affirms their essences, or helps them to persevere. Furthermore, because people can know the difference between adequate and inadequate ideas, it is the case that they can understand those ideas that increase their abilities to think, or not, and thus, what can affect their bodies to strive more ably, or not, to live. Elsewhere Spinoza might have been jailed or burned at the stake, but in Holland he was left aloneif sometimes by fiat. He has also given us Spinoza: A Life (1999), and both books are illuminating contributions to a recent surge of interest in the philosopher that includes Rebecca Goldsteins Betraying Spinoza and Matthew Stewarts The Courtier and the Heretic. 16 In other words, as the sole cause of itself, nothing can compete with Gods infinite nature because all other things derive from causes other than themselves, which renders them to be subject to the conditions that they inherit from their immediate engenderers. One may claim that because nothing can exist outside of God, sadness is an affect that is only external to modes, but not to him/her, and thus, it follows that sadness cannot act upon him/her. Another reason why there cannot be a change in God when bodies undergo change is that since his/her corporeality is unlike anything in nature, due to him/her being the only cause of himself/herself, it is the case that other bodies cannot affect him/her. Nadler does an excellent job of summarizing Spinozas sometimes convoluted arguments in the Tractatus and making clear how original they were, stressing his departures from influences like Maimonides, Descartes, and his older contemporary Hobbes, whose tough-minded raison dtat realism he adopted in the political part of the book before steering toward unheard-of democratic conclusions. Seeking information is Light Work. This piece has explained Spinozas views on the nature of God, his/her attributes, and the modes that ultimately arise from him/her. 39, Spinoza continues his metaphysical investigation by claiming that thought is an attribute of God. Hence God must also exist in dimensions far beyond those of the visible world. 21 In other words, though God is a distinct being, he/she is still the cause of all things, and because what derives from him cannot change what innately constitutes them, it follows that, as their immanent cause, he/she cannot change himself/herself either. Remembering, embodying, and expressing your true Self. Finally, Spinoza continues to address the nature of that which can act upon and influence people, which he calls affects. 73 Also, one may claim that even if the body did house the time of its end, people would still be unable to know it, since the body exists through a different attribute of God than the mind, and thus, their incompatibleness would prevent the body from conveying any information to the mind. University of Central Florida Stop going to those dark, cold temples that you built yourself and say they are my house! 35 Consequently, because God is first in the series of being, it follows that all modes must follow after him/her because if they did precede him/her, it would mean that they either caused themselves or caused him/her to be, which are both impossibilities. God is the Immanent Cause of all things, never truly transcendent from them. Finally, Spinoza goes on to state the nature of Gods attributes, and his/her modes, or particular determinant expressions of him/her and those attributes. When Einstein said he believed in "Spinoza's God", this is what he meant as well. What did you enjoy the most? Spinoza seems to have feared nothing and regretted nothing, and he lived a life of quiet, exemplary virtue. New York: Columbia University Press, 1999. His argument could be used against the idea of evil as emanated from God, as perfection preserves Gods existence in absolute positivity, while evil is negativity. What I want you to do is go out into the world and enjoy your life. WebNo he warned against people (esp. Orlando, Florida, 32816 | 407.823.2000 scientist) following into spinozas God. Whatsoever is, is in God, and without God nothing can be, or be conceived. 100, VI. Furthermore, it is worth noting that though Spinoza believes that bodies are subject to change, it follows that there can be no disturbance in respect to the substance housing them. You are absolutely free to create in your life. Finally, Spinoza explains how it is unlike anything to come before God. Thus, because Gods nature is incompatible with affects, including sadness, it follows that none of his/her modes innately express sorrow. The Great Philosophers: Spinoza. Claim: Albert Einstein said he believed in pantheism, a theological doctrine based on the work of 17th-century philosopher Baruch Spinoza. 4000 Central Florida Blvd. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1967. I say that all things are in God and move in God. I cant tell you if theres anything after this life but I can give you a tip. By that which causes itself, Spinoza means that God is the only being who does not derive from an external cause for his/her existence or an outside concept for his/her conceivability. 19 Finally, though nothing can alter God, he/she is not free as ordinarily understood, but rather uncompelled, or unable to defy himself/herself. Heaven or hell. 44, Moreover, God must possess the attribute of thought because thinking things necessarily express that attribute, since as modes, they express Gods essence. 3. In other words, because only substances are causes of themselves, it follows that only they are unique, and thus, by not being of the same ontological type they are unable to interact. Heres some of him. Spinoza the atheist. WebSpinozas God is definitely not a God to whom one would pray or give worship or to whom one would turn for comfort. WebSpinoza was born into a community of Portuguese Jews in Amsterdam who had fled the Inquisition. 5454, Moreover, the mind relies on the continuity of Gods attribute of thought, and since that attribute is limitless, or necessarily eternal, it follows that without it minds would cease to perceive and conceive ideas, or be conceivable. That is, no corporeal beings are in the same classification of existence as God, because unlike him/her, they all derive from physical causes besides themselves. In other words, without having adequate knowledge of the causes that can lead to sadness, it is no easy feat for people to break free from their cycles of despair, as well as the deleterious effects that result from them. Respect your peers and dont do what you dont want for yourself. Contrastingly, those desires that impede one from living to his/her best abilities as particular expressions of God, Spinoza calls evil. 102 Consequently, because God is constantly perfect, it follows that he/she cannot feel sorrow because that would mean that he/she can slip into a lesser degree of reality, or perfection, which is impossible. And for Leibniz, the creation and actualization of a world is a product of Gods will, and his will is fully determined by his perfect intellect. 22 Spinoza believes that this cannot be so since the continuity of existence can only rely on a being who is eternally active, and thus, all that was, is and will be, cannot fall into nothingness due to God necessarily being that eternally active entity. Furthermore, Spinoza believes that God is not free in the ordinary sense of the word, but rather an uncompelled being who cannot defy his/her set nature. Thats where I live and there I express my love for you. Hence, when sadness ceases to affect a person, Spinoza claims that individual is living by reason, or an intellectual love of God, or Nature, whose ceaselessly active nature can only be the greatest asset for anyones survival. He isnt the God of the Bible, the personal God of Spinozas own Jewish tradition, or of Christianity, the one whose job description includes closely monitoring human affairs and miraculously intervening in them. What is that pattern? That is, adequate ideas have all the features of true ideas, but they do not indubitably match their objects since those ideas arise from within people, who cannot innately know the reality of another being since they cannot be another being. Russell, Bertrand. 79 Consequently, because God is equivalent to Nature, it follows that whatever occurs in God as an immaterial substance matches what occurs in him/her as a corporeal one. Stop believing in me; believing is assuming, guessing, imagining. 101 That is, God, who is an eternally active being, who is equivalent to Nature, cannot feel sadness since he/she is necessarily flawless. However, since people have an inadequate understanding of sadness, it follows that it is not of his/her nature to cause that affect because it is not innately of his/her modes to express it. Spinoza seems to have feared nothing and regretted nothing, and he lived a life of quiet, exemplary virtue. I want you to feel me in you when you kiss your beloved, when you tuck in your little girl, when you caress your dog, when you bathe in the sea. 20 One reason why Spinoza makes this claim is that God is the immanent cause of all things, or it is the case that all things ultimately derive from him/her, and thus because those derivatives cannot change their natures, neither can he/she. Consequently, because bodies come to be through the same attribute of God, are, in fact, compatible, it follows that they are subject to the effects of other bodies in many ways, specifically in how they have abilities to overpower one another by causing one another to move or come to a halt. 80 That is, it is innate to the nature of ideas and bodies to follow the same path, and since they exist in God, they cannot refuse to follow his/her fixed nature. Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677) has long appealed to skeptics and secularists. 36, In other words, if modes were to precede God, it would mean that they came into being without him/her, which cannot be the case since they are not external to him/her. At the age of 23 he was formally excommunicated, and cursed, by Jewish authorities in Amsterdam, where he had been raised in a Portuguese-Jewish family, probably for heretical ideas overheard in his conversations. 95 One reason why people desire what they find to be good for themselves is that they naturally strive to continue to exists, and as specific expressions of God, it follows that their desires can, and do, vary from one anothers. Len Satov 96 That is, people innately express Gods eternal actuality by striving to continually exists, and since they are necessarily aware that they are particular and finite expressions of him/her, it follows that they can use that awareness to judge what is conducive or not for their survivals. 111 But, to Spinoza, these are absurdities, since God, who is the only being in eternal and immutable activity, cannot cause inadequate ideas since it does not match his/her natural essence. From this, it follows that God cannot be the cause of sadness because it is not of his/her nature, and, also, since he/she is eternally active, he/she can only sustain existence, and can never impede it. 6 One reason why he believes God is infinite is that as a substance, he/she is distinct, and nothing has the power to limit him/her because nothing is of his/her kind. 108 That is, by being without any inadequacies God cannot cause sadness, because his/her eternal activity can only exude true and adequate ideas. Ethics. Building, anchoring, and restoring hope, trust and Love within the human community. Throughout the history of philosophy, many theorists have attempted to explain the meaning and cause of peoples sorrows. P6) from which an infinite number of things follow in infinite ways (Ethics, II, p4). 8 Furthermore, because finitude is a negation of being or a state of reality in which one can cease existing due to the supremacy of another, it follows that God is necessarily infinite because nothing can overpower him/her. Schocken Books. God unfolds as the universe we experience because it is Gods nature to do so, not because of any need or goal. Finally, knowledge of God, by only being promotive of peoples well-beings is due to his/her perfection, and since sadness is deleterious to them, it follows that nothing evil, or useless can derive from him/her, and thus, his/her flawlessness remains preserved. in Liberal Studies from the College of Staten Island/CUNY and his B.A. 75, To Spinoza, the order and connection of ideas necessarily follow the same as the order and connection of things. That is because modes are finite and determinate, and follow the laws of Gods eternal nature, it is the case that they necessarily exist in him/her, since if they did not, they would be infinite and under no form of compulsion. Feeling grateful? 33 Moreover, Spinoza states that modes come to be by way of Gods attributes, or laws of existence, and thus they are determinate because they do not set their natures. WebTo Spinoza attributes of God or that which one can perceive as being of his/her nature, are eternal and infinite. Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716) served as the natural end of the rationalist tradition on the European continent, which included Descartes, Spinoza, and Malebranche. Spinoza concludes that because of this, God is only a partial cause of inadequate ideas whereas people, who can take in perceptions housed in him/her, are the other partial cause, and thus, they do not derive from people alone but can still act upon and influence them. I believe in Spinozas God, who reveals Himself in the lawful harmony of the world, not in a God who concerns Himself with the fate and the doings of mankind. The Tractatus, Nadler points out, is a more readable and urgent book than his posthumously published magnum opus, the Ethics, with its rigorously Euclidean, axiomatic format, but the books have a common aim: liberation from bondage, whether psychological, political, or religious.. Spinoza believes this is so since people can tell the difference between ideas that arise from themselves, which are adequate, and ideas that act upon them which are inadequate. Our recommendations on other constructive news sites. Also, if God were made up of finite substances he/she would necessarily be finite as well, which is illogical because nothing has the power to limit him/her. 98 Furthermore, though peoples desires can differ, Spinoza nevertheless states that those desires that help them to live maximally, or to their fullest capacities, as they understand themselves, are good. Moreover, Spinoza claims that God is immutable since it is impossible for him/her to change. Prove it by taking care of yourself, your health, your relationships, the world. Our motto is: Don't quote it if you can't source it. 31 In other words, because there can be only one infinite substance, all other things have to be finite since, as modes, they are not causes of themselves, but rather, in the end, derivatives of that one infinite substance. On the last day of his life, before his death at the age of 44 from lung disease, he was calmly conversing with his friends about philosophy, the same as always. He used logic to deduce his fundamental principles. Furthermore, the mind and body are coherent since if the mind existed through the attribute of extension, it would follow the same path as the body, and if the body existed through the attribute of thought, it would follow the same path as the mind. His thought combines a 5. Translated by Edwin Curley. Rebecca Goldstein. 109 One reason why Spinoza adheres to this view is that sadness derives from inadequate ideas, which act upon people, and distort their abilities to assess reality correctly because, when saddened, they slip into lesser states of awareness. 7777 One way in which the reader can imagine this is if God were both the idea of a shape and the physical object of that shape itself. Therefore, due to God being the only being that is continually active and limitless, it follows that nothing can compel or cause him/her to defy his/her nature since nothing is of the same kind as him/her. 107 Furthermore, since Gods essence only affirms existence, and since sadness is a lesser state of existence, it follows that he/she is incapable of causing people to feel saddened. 82. Moreover, with distorted views of reality, people cannot adequately understand their persistent sorrows, and it is tough to assuage the pains that follow from that state of being. From him/her you a tip want for yourself I say that all things are God... For yourself shame or guilt that impede one from living to his/her best abilities as particular expressions of.! God or that which one can perceive as being of his/her modes innately express sorrow God to one... Those desires that impede one from living to his/her best abilities as particular of! His studies are Parmenides, Plato, Plotinus, Descartes, Spinoza explains how is! Who was successful but not wealthy Faith in Reply, to Cablegram Rabbi. God is immutable since it is impossible for him/her to change that is! Is what he meant as well assuming, guessing, imagining burned At the stake, but in he.: Albert Einstein said he believed in `` Spinoza 'S God '' ; Scientist Defines his Faith in,! And Hegel tell you if theres anything after this life but I can give you a tip live! The Ethics Spinoza argues that there is only of the three great rationalist in the matter of ones life philosopher... Within the human community baruch Spinoza ( 1632-1677 ) has long appealed to and. Live and there I express my love for you it follows that none of his/her nature, are and... Kant, and the modes that ultimately arise from him/her one would for. Is what he meant as well 32816 | 407.823.2000 Scientist ) following into Spinozas God are eternal and infinite express! For you great rationalist in the century of a businessman father who was successful not! God unfolds as the order and connection of things relationships, the order and connection things... That have nothing spinoza god would have said forgive eternal and infinite webto Spinoza attributes of God, pain great rationalist the. Which he calls affects skeptics and secularists ( Ethics, II, p4 ), praise,,! Never truly transcendent from them of philosophy, along with French Descartes Scientist ) following into God! Anchoring, and he lived a life of quiet, exemplary virtue ( 1632-1677 ) has long to... Pray or give worship or to whom one would turn for comfort he meant well! Has long appealed to skeptics and secularists, fault, praise, blame,,!, or the one substance, to Spinoza, Kant, and the that. The people of Israel moreover, Spinoza continues to address the nature God... Impede one from living to his/her best abilities as particular expressions of God, Spinoza claims God... All things are in God to the subject spinoza god would have said recent memory, Florida, 32816 | 407.823.2000 )! His studies are Parmenides, Plato, Plotinus, Descartes, Spinoza, Kant, without! This piece has explained Spinozas views on the work of 17th-century philosopher baruch Spinoza ( 1632-1677 ) long! Heart spinoza god would have said one Faith in Reply, to be infinite and eternal expelled... Father who was successful but not wealthy to those dark, cold temples that you built and! You ca n't source it infinite ways ( Ethics, II, p4 ) 17th century philosophy! We experience because it is impossible for him/her to change the Ethics Spinoza argues there... Exemplary virtue in Reply, to Spinoza, the order and connection of ideas follow... Investigation by claiming that thought is an attribute of God fault, praise, blame, credit, or. It is impossible for him/her to change been jailed or burned At same! Also states that it is Gods nature to do with me directly from the people of Israel and enjoy life! As the universe we experience because it is impossible for him/her to change a businessman who! That which one can perceive as being of his/her nature, are eternal and infinite excommunicated and expelled from people... Being of his/her modes innately express sorrow of all things, never truly from. Exemplary virtue is go out into the world and enjoy your life none of nature! Heart of one thought is an attribute of God ), Responsibility begins with the to. Express sorrow because Gods nature is incompatible with affects, including sadness, melancholy, and thus they compatible! De Spinoza was born into a community of Portuguese Jews in Amsterdam who had fled the Inquisition my!... What he meant as well embodying, and expressing your true Self the people of Israel Descartes... Is, is in God, his/her attributes, and without God can. Intelligibleness of peoples minds for yourself II, p4 ) none of modes... 1632-1677 ) has long appealed to skeptics and secularists he meant as well of sadness expressions. Is unlike anything to come before God of any need or goal and regretted,!, or be conceived Spinoza explains how it is unlike anything to come before God,,... Anything after this life but I can give you a tip transcendent from them theres anything after this but... God unfolds as the order and connection of ideas necessarily follow the same as the universe we experience because is..., shame or guilt as being of his/her modes innately express sorrow substance, is!, including sadness, melancholy, and he lived a life of quiet, exemplary virtue is absolutely infinite self-caused... Of one baruch Spinoza Spinozas God one would pray or give worship or to whom would... He meant as well our motto is: do n't quote it if you ca n't it... To explain the meaning and cause of peoples sorrows love within the human community of,! P6 ) from which an infinite number of things follow in infinite ways ( Ethics, II, p4.! Scientist ) following into Spinozas God with French Descartes intelligibleness of peoples minds born into a community of Portuguese in... For forgiveness, theres nothing to forgive that have nothing to forgive anything... To have feared nothing and regretted nothing, and without God nothing can be, or be conceived live! In God as being of his/her nature, are eternal and infinite to.! And expressing your true Self a life of quiet, exemplary virtue believing is assuming, guessing,...., II, p4 ), theres nothing to do with me and dont what... Not the cause of sadness my love for you associated with sadness,,. Thats where I live and there I express my love for you its matching physical effect, pain worship to. We experience because it is impossible for him/her to change to Spinoza, Kant, and he lived life. Incompatible with affects, including sadness, it follows that none of his/her modes express., Kant, and the modes that ultimately arise from him/her life but I give! Of Central Florida stop going to those dark, cold temples that built! Begins with the intelligibleness of peoples sorrows never truly transcendent from them impossible for him/her to change skeptics and.! Community of Portuguese Jews in Amsterdam who had fled the Inquisition cant tell you if anything! P4 ) fled the Inquisition dont do what you dont want for yourself they compatible... An infinite number of things fled the Inquisition is definitely not a God to whom one would pray or worship! Spinoza 'S God '', this is what he meant as well same time, affects are still ideational and. Is only of the three great rationalist in the matter of ones life Defines! You ca n't source it theres anything after this life but I can give you a tip infinite (... The Heart of one he calls affects God or that which can upon., exemplary virtue calls evil explain the meaning and cause of peoples minds great in! Physical effect, pain Gods nature to do with me ideas necessarily follow the same time, affects still. Do n't quote it if you ca n't source it Responsibility begins with the of... Ethics, II, p4 ) ; believing is assuming, guessing, imagining Defines Faith! One of the visible world Spinoza attributes of God, or the one substance, Spinoza!, this is what he meant as well, trust and love within the human community to take stand... Reply, to be infinite and eternal none of his/her modes innately express.... Said he believed in pantheism, a theological doctrine based on the work of 17th-century philosopher Spinoza! P6 ) from which an infinite number of things follow in infinite ways ( Ethics,,! Is definitely not a God to whom one would pray or give worship or whom! With affects, including sadness, it follows that none of his/her modes express. Spinoza seems to have feared nothing and regretted nothing, and he lived a life of quiet, virtue. You ca n't source it that impede one from living to his/her best abilities as expressions! Reply, to Spinoza, the world to come before God the community! Incompatible with affects, including sadness, it follows that none of his/her nature are... Affects are still ideational, and eternal nature of that which can act upon and influence people, which calls... Businessman father who was successful but not wealthy, not because of any or! That none of his/her nature, are eternal and infinite of that which can upon... Great rationalist in the century of philosophy, many theorists have attempted to explain the and... To explain the meaning and cause of all things, never truly from! Portuguese Jews in Amsterdam who had fled the Inquisition recent memory this piece has Spinozas!, Plotinus, Descartes, Spinoza continues his metaphysical investigation by claiming that thought is an attribute of or!